Russ Tamblyn
as Gideon Pontipee
Russell Simpson
as Fred Bixby
Ian Wolfe
as The Rev. Elcott
Marjorie Wood
as Mrs. Fred Bixby
Howard Keel
as Adam Pontipee
Jane Powell
as Milly Pontipee
Jeff Richards
as Benjamin Pontipee
Tommy Rall
as Frank Pontipee
Matt Mattox
as Caleb Pontipee
Jacques d'Amboise
as Ephraim Pontipee
Virginia Gibson
as Liza
Julie Newmeyer
as Dorcas
Ruta Kilmonis
as Ruth
Nancy Kilgas
as Alice
Betty Carr
as Sarah
Norma Doggett
as Martha
Howard Petrie
as Pete Perkins
Earl Barton
as Harry
Dante DiPaolo
as Matt
Kelly Brown
as Carl
Dick Rich
as Dorcas' father