John Lloyd Young
Erich Bergen
as Bob Gaudio
Michael Lomenda
as Nick Massi
Renée Marino
as Mary
Erica Piccininni
as Lorraine
Joseph Russo
as Joey
Donnie Kehr
as Norm Waxman
Steven Schirripa
as Vito
Johnny Cannizzaro
as Nick DeVito
Lacey Hannan
as Angela